High-rise plan for racecourse
Jason Dowling
April 4, 2011 
The proposed development site at Moonee Valley Racecourse.
A $1.4 BILLION project to build more than 2000 apartments and townhouses at the Moonee Valley racecourse – including four high-rise towers – will put the historical track at the forefront of Melbourne’s battle to provide housing for its booming population.
The proposed residential and commercial development, including four towers more than 20 storeys high, is the centrepiece of a master plan to be released by the Moonee Valley Racing Club within weeks.
The towers will be built in existing car parks, with all parking at the track that holds one of Australia’s premier race meetings – the Cox Plate – to be moved to the centre of the course.
The Moonee Valley club has briefed Planning Minister Matthew Guy and Racing Minister Denis Napthine on its development plans and is working with the Moonee Valley Council on the final touches of the master plan for the 40-hectare site that could house 6000 people.
Mr Guy said that while he was not responsible for approving the master plan, he was ”supportive of inner-city urban renewal on sites such as this”.
Melbourne’s other racecourses – Flemington, with its own dedicated rail line, and Caulfield, next to a major train station – are also keen to unlock their abundant land for residential developments.
The push for racecourse housing will be boosted by figures revealed by The Age last week showing Melbourne is Australia’s fastest-growing capital city – adding more than 1500 people a week. The figures showed that the four fastest-growing municipalities in the country were on Melbourne’s fringe.
It also comes as Latrobe City Council in the Latrobe Valley seeks the rezoning by the state government of 574 hectares of land for residential housing on the edges of its major towns: Traralgon, Morwell, Moe/Newborough and Churchill (see story page 6).
This is in addition to 232 hectares in Latrobe that the government recently rezoned for residential housing. In total, the land-release package would provide enough area to develop an estimated 8055 to 12,090 properties.
The Baillieu government is desperate to identify quality sites in Melbourne for new residential development as the population booms, and racecourses are considered ideal development areas close to public transport and with lots of land now used for car parking.
But the size of the proposed Moonee Valley development has angered some local residents, who are concerned about the impact on services of thousands more people.
The racing club’s chief executive, Michael Browell, said extensive public consultation would be undertaken before the master plan for Moonee Valley, where races were first held in 1883, was finalised.
”We have got a full and comprehensive community consultation process set to begin at this stage in late April, early May,” he said.
He said it would be a ”10 to 14-week community consultation process where the local community will have the opportunity to have a look at what we have proposed, provide feedback and then we will amend our plans accordingly”.
Mr Browell said the residential towers would overlook the racetrack furthest from existing housing. ”The majority of the development would be on the western side of the existing racecourse land, which is Dean Street, McPherson Street, down through Thomas Street,” he said.
Mr Browell said the racing club was in a ”fantastic” position with freehold land in an area designated for major development.
”All up, we are projecting the gross value in the redevelopment could be upwards of $1.25 to $1.4 billion, and then the club would be looking to net roughly $300 million, so that we can invest that back into a new racetrack and grandstands and have some surplus funds left over,” he said.
Opposition planning spokesman Brian Tee questioned why the minister was being briefed on the plan before the local residents.
”Here we have got the minister and the developer hand-in-hand and the public are being left out,” he said. ”Why is the public always the last to know?”
In response to concerns about Melbourne’s rampant growth, Premier Ted Baillieu said yesterday that his government was being forced to play catch-up with its planning policies because the former Labor government had done so little to deal with the city’s unprecedented population boom. Mr Baillieu said Labor had virtually ignored the consequences as it chased a higher population to sustain economic growth.
The Age revealed last week that Melbourne had grown by 605,000 residents, the equivalent of six Ballarats, in the nine years to 2010, pushing out the city’s urban boundaries and increasing pressure on transport infrastructure and housing affordability.
Mr Baillieu said his government was concerned about the boom and its effects on Melbourne’s infrastructure. ”In the last 10 years … we haven’t seen the planning or the investment,” he said.
”What we’ve seen is population growth become an end in itself. ”The previous government became dependent on population growth for economic growth. [The state government] is going to be in a situation where we have to catch up because this state has fallen behind in the investment in the core infrastructure and the core facilities … It’s not something that we can do overnight.”
But Mr Tee said Mr Baillieu had still not presented an alternative vision on how to fix Melbourne’s problems. ”Mr Baillieu is choosing to act like an opposition leader rather than a premier by failing to outline how he will make sure Victorians have access to the services and facilities they will need in the future,” he said.
”It’s time Mr Baillieu wakes up and realises reviews, delaying important projects and dithering over every decision won’t build new infrastructure, hospitals or schools. Only vision, planning and hard work will.”
April 4, 2011 at 10:44 AM
Development is now the money making ventures for racing clubs. That much is clear. It’s ironic that non profit organisations have decided to become major capitalists. There’s one difference between Moonee Valley and Caulfield though – the centre of their racecourse is feehold and not crown land. Otherwise they’ve obviously adopted the caulfield template and will work this for all they can. I just wonder how compliant their council will be in contrast to Glen Eira.
April 5, 2011 at 6:27 PM
Yes that is a big difference. The Moonee Valley Racing Club is all private land , but the Caulfield Reserve was set aside for racing,recreation and a public park by Queen Victoria. The triangle which is supposed to have been valued and acts as part of a swap looked like a sale at a bargain price. The rates for this area of over 125 acres have been charged according to their classification as a park and entertainment area and (of course it is not) a full rate charged as it was only
$ 150,000 for that large area only a year or two ago. So we are paying their way again. In addition we have our streets jammed, crowded beyond reason often closed by them or their agents without notice to us. We also have to walk past many empty beer bottles and much broken glass from their liquor vending business. Also the MRC displayed a sign that “forbad persons from carrying an unoppened alcoholic drink along several of the nearby streets on the way to the north and west of the racecourse. The “octupus” spreads it’s tentacles so we have to go west to buy our beers!
April 5, 2011 at 8:57 PM
This is a disgrace….high-density high rise buildings in Moonee Ponds….absolutely ridiculous. Are we in Hong Kong or Melbourne?
I think the fix is in….
April 9, 2011 at 5:41 PM
Read the Moonee Valley Racing Club’s announcement to its members of this monstrous Dubai/Hong Kong-like development and you’d think it wasn’t neighbours with streets of residents which in the main have been living in harmony with it. Stuff the neighbours we’re living cheek by jowel with, say MVRC, this development of four 20 storey towers and accommodation for 6000 people will give us money left over to increase race prize money. Some neighbour!
April 9, 2011 at 8:28 PM
We now have massive Racing over developments in Flemington, Moonee Valley and Caulfield which will yield the racing fraternity something like 2 billion. And yet daily the newspapers are full of stories re not enough money in state government coffers or how prices increases are causing a severe strain on the public. Isn’t it time that the government and local council’s did away with the generous subsidies handed out to the racing community and started charging commercial rental for crown land and residential rates for the racecourses. We could also do away with the $14m per year in unclaimed bets that Napthine says is their money (yeah like all unclaimed/inactive deposits belong to the banks).
October 7, 2011 at 12:38 PM
Our population continues to expand rapidly, yet we expect our cities to be frozen in time. Areas like Moonee Ponds are relatively close to the city centre and should expect developments that condense the population.
I’m sure the early settlers of the area were not fond of subdivisions and urbaniaation. Times change. We must learn to adapt.
October 7, 2011 at 12:55 PM
People who live in Moonee Ponds have become very accustomed to development and definitely don’t expect it to be a city frozen in time. It’s all about living in harmony with new neighbours and new developments being created that enhance this lovely leafy residential area.