Tonight’s community forum on the ‘Community Plan’ was in many respects a pleasant surprise. It was certainly much improved on what occurred several years ago. However, we will withhold judgement until the draft plan is published to see exactly the extent to which council has taken residents’ views to heart. The turnout of residents was excellent with approximately 60 attending.
The chronology of the evening was as follows:
- Hyams gave a little speech emphasising how much Council had listened to the community on the last consultation. Examples of such ‘listening’ and action included – planting 600 trees every year; buying land at Packer Park; sporting fields re-turfing; graffiti removal. This lasted for approximately 10 minutes.
- Mark Saunders introduced what the evening was about – ie ‘themes’ both in depth and that people can also listen to others and ‘valuing’ others’ views. Reminded audience that consultation doesn’t mean that people necessarily get what they want. (5 minutes)
- Peter Jones went over the OCR consultant’s report and highlighted the methodology – ie. 500 telephone ’interviews’; focus groups, etc. Outlined when the draft plan would be released (April) and then sent out again for public consultation.
People were invited to sit around 6 tables and were provided with 3 different coloured note pads. They were asked to write down what they considered to be the three main issues or challenges facing the municipality or their neighbourhood. Each priority was to be written down on a separate sheet. These were then pinned up on a wall and collated. Each table assigned one speaker to report back on the priorities. (30 minutes).
The major issues identified were not surprising – Planning, overdevelopment, traffic management, parking, open space, trees, transparency/consultation in council; rubbish collection and street littering; racecourse; high rates.
The rest of the evening involved a ‘visionary’ exercise where people were asked to list things that they would like to see in Glen Eira in 20 years time and what they wanted to see go. Again, the lists were predictable: amenity protection; better uban design and development; open space; crime and safety issues; parking sorted out; better aged care and child care; more open space purchases.
As we’ve previously said, there can be no doubt as to the issues which are causing the greatest angst for residents – the lack of appropriate planning that covers traffic management and open space, as well as good governance. The ball is now firmly in Council’s court. They may have listened, but the question remains – will they act?
February 13, 2012 at 11:15 PM
I went along this evening really out of curiousity. I agree with the post that most people were really worried about planning and overdevelopment. But, there wasn’t enough opportunity for people to have a good say to the whole audience. A couple of people grabbed the microphone and it was obvious that they didn’t want these folks to continue speaking. The general feeling I got was that people are getting really pissed off with this council and what they see as inaction. There was also a slide that listed the things that people like about living in Glen Eira and most of the items had absolutely nothing to do with how good or rotten council was like public transport, schools. This was in the phone surveys so it tells me straight off how useless this consultant’s paper is.
February 13, 2012 at 11:18 PM
The process has already been rigged via the telephone survey, we will never know the questions asked in this survey, or the answers given
This bogus information from this secret survey will be used to deliver the predetermined outcomes the CEO wants. The public meetings are just there to provide the appearance that the public has been consulted
Off course the CEO gets Jamie Hyams to front-up and make the process look legitimate
You can fool some of the people all the time, and all of the people some of the time, but you cannot fool all of the people all the time.
Abe Lincoln
February 13, 2012 at 11:21 PM
The OCR Report does list the questions asked! What’s highly questionable is the order of these questions!
February 13, 2012 at 11:19 PM
Jamie me boy, ya can’t help yourself can ya? Ya have to keep spewing out the bullshit and boring the pants off everyone with this tripe. Guess that’s worth 90 thousand!
February 14, 2012 at 8:46 AM
On behalf of all the readers of this blog I would like to thank you for such a meaningful and worthwhile contribution. Please keep up your good work. not.