The next Kingston Council Meeting set down for June 2nd should be well worth watching on their live streaming. Several Notices of Motion stand out for their call for greater transparency and accountability and hence overall governance practices. None of these, of course, could ever happen in Glen Eira given the current status of Meeting Procedures as well as a culture that shuns public scrutiny on all matters.
Here are the most ‘interesting’ items –
(Councillor Bearsley) – I Move
A. That council launches an independent review of the following areas in order of priority:
a. Community Engagement
b. Economic Development
c. Communications
d. Statutory Planning
B. That council scopes a tender process for an efficiency and effectiveness report for whole of council to be compiled by a reputable accounting/auditing firm and completed no later than August 2014.
C. That council develops an annual assessment and review process of efficiency and effectiveness of the council organisation with appropriate reporting measures which improve accountability and transparency.
D. That performance reporting KPIs be incorporated as part of an annual review.
(Cr Eden) – I move that:
Kingston Council seek to appoint an independently appointed observer to explore whether there are poor practices at Kingston Council, and whether Councillors have been acting in a questionable manner with respect to Planning matters.
(Cr Bearsley) – I move :
I move that planning officers prepare a report that details all developments, over the past two years, that have significantly breached the approved permit conditions and required amendment/resolution. The report is to indicate the breach, address, owner/applicant and final outcome. The report should include ways Kingston identify and minimise such breaches occurring and be provided by the 30th June.
(Cr Eden) – I move :
1. Council record the ‘in camera’ part of the Council meeting, so that if & when the item(s) are later made public the debate / discussion accompanying the confidential item will also be available to the public.
2. That officers report to Council on the reasons for ‘glitches / errors’ in the live recording and streaming of council meetings, and possible actions to rectify these problems, including:
a) That officers explore alternative mechanisms for recording the sound generated at meetings to ensure that regardless of whether the person speaking has their microphone on, their comments will be recorded – this will ensure if there is debate /discussions around the room that such comments are captured.
b) Officers implement a system to ensure that the live recording / streaming is working during meetings, and that Councillors are immediately notified if there are ‘technical issues’.
++++++++++
Another agenda item includes an indepth report on items declared ‘confidential’ which is well worth reading.
May 29, 2014 at 12:00 PM
Why would you quote or mention anything about Kingston Council.Anyone in the Industry knows that Kingston Councillors are at each others throats and deeply divided. It is a useless Council and if you doubt this go for a drive . PS watch out for the potholes and wear gumboots.
May 29, 2014 at 12:29 PM
Are they any more divided that Glen Eira? I doubt it. All is appearance here and keeping things quiet. You can’t tell me that Lobo doesn’t hate the gang’s guts. At least Kingston council hasn’t been dismissed and hasn’t had heaps of inspectors looking at them or nor have they spent a fortune on lawyers. There should be an independent investigation into cost efficiency and how much money Newton wastes every single year. And while they’re at it they should also have a good close look at the wheeling and dealing that went on with the Melbourne racing club and plenty of other planning applications. Who is mates with whom is the bottom line I reckon.
May 29, 2014 at 12:40 PM
Lobo hates both gangs.
May 29, 2014 at 2:19 PM
….ever since he missed out on the role of Mayor.
May 29, 2014 at 2:39 PM
Whiteside resigning in disgust
June 1, 2014 at 9:43 AM
What about the harassment dished out to young Nick Staikos in his first term as the youngest Councillor in Glen Eira. Hard time given by Lipshutz and Hyams, What about Frank P?. What about Lobo and what appeared in the local newspaper late 2013 on the front pages. What about Whiteside termed as an useless Councillor and a Mayor by Lipshutz in the Age late 2012? Is there no one to take the gang to task????.
June 1, 2014 at 9:45 AM
……..Oh yes, what about the icing on the cake, Hyams calling Rosetta a whinging bitch in public? Why was he not taken for investigations and why did the newspaper not report about this incident? Is pressure being applied to the newspaper and they are now gagged?
May 29, 2014 at 1:49 PM
I think that the motions are commendable. If councils are serious about improving their performance and being as cost effective as possible, then there should be and independent review undertaken of all facets of the organisation. Ratepayers should know if they are getting value for money.
Planning is a vital area and the failure of councils to enforce permit conditions is legendary. No such statistics are reported in Glen Eira. They should be in exactly the same way that permit extensions should be reported but which this administration doesn’t believe is necessary. Much that happens within planning is with held from residents. I have yet to see a full report on delegated planning decisions.
The last motion listed in the post is for me the most important since the numbers of confidential items in Glen Eira reaches prolific proportions with no reporting back. This also applied to advisory groups where reports are presented for discussion but residents never get to see what the reports actually say and so there is voting on these recommendations without any transparency or open discussion. To me that’s a perversion of the law and only works to further remove public input and oversight. All in all the motions are worthy of debate and I will be watching.
May 29, 2014 at 8:00 PM
I have no interest in tennis at all but I think it is really sad that we are losing sporting space to a multi unit development (notice up on fence). With all these extra people and nothing to do we will soon be a urban ghetto and we all know what the teenagers will be doing if there is nothing else for them to do.
From their facebook page
St Anthony’s Tennis Club – Glenhuntly
2 minutes ago
Dear Members and to all our extended family and friends in the broader community
It is with great regret that St Anthony’s Tennis Club” have been advised that Catholic Homes are pursuing a permit to build on the land in which “St Anthony’s Tennis Club” occupies.
Over the last 100 years the tennis club has been a cornerstone for the community providing
A place to meet, socialise, congregate and play tennis in a safe and friendly environment, with people from all races, genders, ages and ethnicities.
A strong affiliation with the St Anthony’s Parish Primary School, and local schools in the area
Strong values through sport for our current and future generations
Coaching programs for approximately 135 people (many being parishioners) including a number of students with disabilities. Children coaching and squads run Monday to Saturday as well as before school and lunchtime classes.
Social Tennis Sessions with everyone welcomed
Mixed Doubles Competition being played across Bayside as well as the Midweek Ladies Competition
Four Junior teams participating in the 2013/14 VCLTA Junior Summer Competition, involving over 30 players and their families. Two of the teams won the premiership in their respective grading. For the 2014 VCLTA Junior Winter Competition, we have three teams participating, including a team in Section 1 of the competition.
Significant use of the courts between 25-35 hours weekly and anticipated to grow over time with the growth of the community.
Employment to a highly qualified, friendly and reliable Coach and his assistants
The Tennis Club has a deep history of being a family club, welcoming people from all walks of life. Glenhuntly continues to be an area which attracts many devout Catholics some being young migrants with young children. The good service St Anthony’s Parish has historically provided the community needs to continue for these families with a “complete” service – This must include the tennis club, Sunday children’s liturgy and instruction for the sacraments. Having a tennis club encourages people to be involved in parish life for many years to come
In times of increased obesity and less sport and recreation, the tennis club is there for its parishioners and the community.
Use of the tennis club house for community based meetings such as Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) and others.
The Tennis Club endeavours to build on the good work it has done over the years; many of the club members have spent countless hours volunteering to raise much needed funds for the church in raffles and Bingo. The Church has been able to purchase numerous blocks of land due to this very good work. Some of this land would make a fantastic alternative to the land being proposed.
The Tennis Club also wishes to continue to grow its affiliation with St Anthony’s Parish Primary School, if the Club continues to remain at its current location there are options to make the courts into a multi purpose surface which can be used by the school for other sports such as Netball, hockey or basketball. This will be a major draw-card for the school to attract a greater number of new students and also providing the current students with “A Grade” Open Air Facilities.
St Anthony was venerated all over the world as the Patron Saint for lost articles, and is credited with many miracles involving lost people, lost things and even lost spiritual goods.
We pray that that this gem of a tennis club is not lost to the future generations that may need it one day.
With Kindest Regards,
St Anthony’s Tennis Club.
June 1, 2014 at 11:46 PM
Maybe council could purchase this land and maybe the courts could be made available to the public as well as leasing them back to club members, and even the unused land there could be a small playground as there are many thousands of residents in the Koornang/Neerim Road area and they have no park nearby, council could also negotiate to lease/purchase the land at Neerim Road gates for a pop-up park, and the land to the south of the railway near where the Dandenong and Frankston lines separate which is for sale. Also now that the south of railway is to be completely covered by the “unstoppable buildings” a councillor’s utterance then council should develop the area to the north of the railway with a low fence, seats and some play equipment for shoppers and public transport passengers and their children.
June 2, 2014 at 10:16 AM
Don’t expect all that to happen through the likes of Newton, Lipshutz and Hyams. It needs proactive residents just to save St Anthony’s tennis courts. I recall Newton wanting to flog off the Bute Street tennis courts for development and that was on land donated to Council by a resident long ago. Newton was livid that the residents were successful in challenging the sale. Would have funded at least two more Council junkets…