Glen Eira Council has sat on its backside for the past 13 years and basically reneged on all its promises. Two years in and the impacts of the zones are obvious to everyone – especially those residents living in the ‘sacrificial’ suburbs where there is inadequate protection, no design guidelines, no preferred character statements, no structure planning, no parking precinct plans. And yet Council and its sycophantic coucillors will not do a thing to correct one iota of its countless errors and slipshod strategic planning.
We have pointed out time and time again how other councils are rushing through amendment after amendment in order to redress their zones and the mistakes they now identify. Glen Eira is waiting until high tide when every suburb is thrashed and it is too late to do anything!
Even Greater Dandenong, which was the second council to rush through its zones in November 2013, is starting to see the error of its ways. It is now advertising and seeking community input on a new amendment which will substantially change much of the zoning that was introduced in 2013.
Below we feature extracts taken from the officer’s report (minutes of June 25th 2015) and a screen dump of the suggested changes. Please take careful note of these changes and the additional research undertaken. In Glen Eira the Housing Strategy (circa 1998) belongs in the dustbin of history as does most of the current planning scheme for its inconsistencies, its irrelevance and its lack of detail and concerted effort to protect neighbourhoods. We’ve bolded certain sections for greater emphases and ask residents to compare these statements to what has come out of Glen Eira.
The new residential zones were applied with the understanding that the Residential Growth Zone (RGZ) near the major shopping centres of Dandenong, Springvale and Noble Park would be reviewed to achieve preferred design outcomes for particular areas, better manage growth and continue to balance the needs of the community and landowners.
However it was identified that further policy, planning controls and research work was required in the Residential Growth Zone / Substantial Change Area to clarify the preferred urban landscape in these areas. This will increase certainty for local residents and the development community and improve built form outcomes. Planning consultants, Planisphere, were engaged and commenced this work, including comprehensive community consultation through the Greater Dandenong Residential Planning Policy and Controls Project
In particular, the Project:
Examined the new residential zones and accompanying schedules and the opportunity they present to give clear direction to Council’s housing objectives; and Aimed to improve the quality and amenity of new housing development by strengthening the urban design policies in Council’s Residential Development and Neighbourhood Character Policy (Clause 22.09); and Where appropriate, recommended additional variations to the ResCode standards and building height controls.
The review of the current planning provisions found that not only are the areas designated for ‘substantial’ change expansive, but the purposes of the new residential zones imply a degree of change for that area exceeds the built form outcomes anticipated in the Municipal Strategic Statement and the Residential Development and Neighbourhood Character Policy. These findings led to the preparation of a refined Residential Framework, a revision of the Substantial Change Areas boundaries, improved design principles in the local policy, additional variations to the ResCode standards and the specification of building height controls for different residential areas.
Planning Scheme Amendment C182 proposes to:
Amend the existing Schedules to the Residential Zones and introduce a new Schedule 3 to the Residential Growth Zone;
The amendment seeks to rezone identified areas in Dandenong and Noble Park from Residential Growth Zone to General Residential Zone to reflect the revised Residential Framework and achieve a transition in built form while ensuring that the identified valued neighbourhood character and amenity of established residential areas is protected.
Direct notification of the proposed changes will be provided to all owners and occupiers of land within the current Residential Growth Zone and land proposed to be rezoned (approximately 9,000 letters). In addition to the minimum notifications prescribed by the Act, the above notifications will be accompanied by an explanatory brochure that will provide a summary of the proposed changes for the community
As this is a complex planning scheme amendment, a range of materials will be provided to help explain the proposed changes to the community:
Four Information Drop-In Sessions will be held in Dandenong, Noble Park and Springvale during the exhibition period to provide residents with an opportunity to talk directly with planning officers and ask questions about the proposed changes;
Notice on Council’s website will include an interactive map where residents will be able to check if their street is affected by the proposed changes
October 29, 2015 at 4:42 PM
Interesting. Glen Eira’s zoning is a blanket 13.5 and 10.5 and then 8 metres for neighbourhood residential. The Dandenong one makes a lot more sense since general residential zone will only be 9 metres and if next to the 8 metres won’t stick out like a sore thumb that is happening in Glen Eira where there are many 3 storeys right against the neighbourhood residential homes. Permeability is better too. Good on Dandenong for the work they’ve done.
October 29, 2015 at 6:13 PM
Nothing has been done cos this council doesn’t have the necessary skills to attempt structure planning or anything else. To get in consultants costs money and they don’t have a cracker to spend on anything except pavilions, concrete, and more oval grasses. Any changes would not go down to well with their developer friends either. Better to sit and do nothing and blame vcat and the government.
October 29, 2015 at 8:49 PM
Hope lies in the new ceo and a monumental effort to fix the culture and planning of the place. Starters should be getting rid of the no hopers and bringing in some super duper people who give a stuff about people.
October 29, 2015 at 10:24 PM
FYI we believe that residents should have a close listen to item 10.4, 10.5 and 10.6 from the last Bayside City Council meeting. The link is – http://stream.bayside.vic.gov.au/archive/video15-1027.php
Then simply click on the item number featured below the videocast.
We highlight this since:
1. It deals with Bayside’s recent amendments to introduce mandatory height controls in its Major Activity Centres – ie Bay St., Church St. etc. The proposed height controls COVERS COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES as well.
2. The amendments went to a planning panel and the panel recommended abandoning the amendments
3. Bayside however is sticking to its guns and proceeding with the amendments – wanting the minister to okay them
4. We wonder how many Glen Eira residents would get up at a council meeting and praise the work of their councillors as some residents do here?!!!!
5. Please also note that Bayside allows residents to address council – even welcomes it, plus the fact that residents are able to view the discussion. Again a very strong ‘no-no’ in Glen Eira.
6. All of this is just another example of what is happening in other councils and the efforts they are making, compared to the refusal to do anything in Glen Eira except wait until it is too late.
October 29, 2015 at 11:02 PM
What a fantastic, open, transparent and accountable way of presenting meeting procedure by streaming it live. And what do we have in Glen Eira? Audio recording, which is not even available to Councillors, let alone the public. Yagh.
October 30, 2015 at 6:49 AM
Maybe a new CEO will look at video casting Council meetings in the future.
October 30, 2015 at 8:37 AM
With the exiting of Mr. Newton, maybe our more progressive councillors could look at redressing our lack Notice of Notice, if this was done it may help the councillors wrest some control back from the bureaucrats to the community.
October 30, 2015 at 11:42 AM
Correction that would be “Notice of Motion procedure ”
This is a procedure where any councillor can follow a set of rules or procedures and place an (Item or Motion) onto the Agenda for a upcoming council meeting.
Glen Eira is the only council in Victoria and possible Australia where this procedure is denied to our Councillors and thus our community, it was removed from our Local Law by Newton.
The result is the CEO has total control of what appears on the Agenda.
This mean they can only discuss what he want them to discuss.
This further means we elect councillors to represent us, but they have no mechanism under our Local Law, Meeting Procedures Act, to represent us. Over the years this has turned our councillors into becoming rubber stampers.
Most newly elected councillors to Glen Eira think this is the normal procedure for business and that’s how it’s done. And know one ever tells them anything different.
The Liberal Party faction on the council are very happy with this monopoly situation, and actively police this (MODERATORS: part of sentence deleted) from this rubber stamping.
This how it’s done in Glen Eira, and that’s why we are in such a mess
October 30, 2015 at 11:43 AM
good news. Looks like they are setting up a circus tent at Caulfield Racecourse on their non existant lease
October 30, 2015 at 4:34 PM
It’s Newtons and PB last performance, called “Clowns In Business Suits” It’s been leaked they’re not that funny. I guess that could have expected