Elsternwick structure plan
Mr SOUTHWICK (Caulfield)
My adjournment today is to the Minister for Planning, and the action I seek is that the minister immediately defer any decisions on the Glen Eira council structure plan, which will see massive overdevelopment, particularly within the areas of Elsternwick, until such time as residents are properly consulted.
Today I tabled a petition from 1300 residents around the Elsternwick precinct. Many of them live in homes of heritage value. Some of those homes date back to the late 1880s. They are very, very concerned about the overdevelopment that is happening throughout my electorate of Caulfield. This master plan which the Glen Eira council is proposing could certainly see loss of character and amenity and massive overdevelopment, which would see some single –storey homes being completely taken over by large towers in the area.
These residents need to be consulted, and we certainly want to make sure that we do not take up the squeeze that is being left behind from the protection that the Bentleigh residents have had in the overall precinct. We know that there is development need for housing, but Caulfield should not bear the brunt of that. The master plan sees a 20 per cent increase in population and we do not want to squeeze all of that into areas like Elsternwick.
The Liberals’ plan has already been stated. We will reintroduce a two -dwelling limit on neighbourhood residential zones, reduce height limits in neighbourhood residential zones and bring back the 9 –metre discretionary height limit in general residential zones. Certainly this would make a huge difference to many of those residents that I am talking about. But we do not want to see this rushed through. We have got an election in November, and we think that the residents should have the opportunity for proper consultation, not rush things through quickly before the election so people do not have the ability to have proper consultation. We saw the attempted rush through of the Ormond sky tower, and certainly we had to intervene in the upper house with that. We have seen Bethlehem Hospital propose 16 storeys in Kooyong Road. We are seeing massive overdevelopment through Caulfield. Enough is enough, and we are asking the Minister for Planning on this occasion to step in and make sure no decisions are made whatsoever until such time as the issues about excessive height and issues with car parking, traffic and general congestion in our area are fully explored and residents are properly consulted and protected when it comes to living in the great suburbs of Elsternwick, Caulfield and the broader City of Glen Eira.
June 22, 2018 at 10:56 AM
Some interim height controls would be appropriate!
June 22, 2018 at 11:20 AM
Not if they are twelve storeys and no proper studies done.
June 22, 2018 at 11:07 AM
Good grief Mr. Southwick who would be fooled by this insincere outburst.
What is he saying about proper consultation, like who or what? The Matthew Guy model of community consultation when he was Planning Minister.
We know Mr. Guy has already had his lobster dinner with his developer mates. The deals have been cooked and the under the table handshakes have been done.
Call me a cynic but I really, really doubt that public consultation was in their round table discussion between gulps of Penfolds Grange and mouthfuls of Lobster.
June 22, 2018 at 1:14 PM
Yes Mary DeveloperHunty – I call you a cynic.
No insincere outburst here, but the result of hard work on the behalf of locals who were not consulted because City of Glen Eira know this development will destroy their quality of life.
So much for the Australian dream… this development means if I wish to have a summer afternoon bbq with my mates at my humble home that has taken an entire working life to achieve I must do it in the shade with 2000 extra eyes watching.
No lobster and grange for me, just a few snags and beers with good friends and possibly the cricket destroyed so the council can get their extra rates and their palms greased.
No I don’t call you a cynic… I have a better word to describe you with.
June 22, 2018 at 3:36 PM
and Hyams MaGee Esakoff who have done nothing in planning and allowed this to occur
June 23, 2018 at 3:27 AM
(MODERATORS: sentence deleted)
Southwick, work hard, steady on there, has his printer been running overtime printing diploma and associate professor certificates, I must admit that so much harder than doing the work to actually earn the real thing.
Am I wrong, or just being cynical again?
June 24, 2018 at 3:15 PM
As in… the locals working very hard (guess I was not very clear on who did the work – sorry). Funny thing is, I normally vote left of centre but if Southwark is going to bat for our cause then I will indeed be sending my support that way.
The ones who are actually feasting on lobster are our councillors who are clearly enjoying letting down their constituents.
June 24, 2018 at 9:45 PM
The funny thing is ……. you’re more likely a paid Liberal Party propagandist working out of a MP office. You “normally vote left of centre” ….. come on pull the other one.
Anyone who thinks Southwick is going to be their neighbourhood savior is totally deluded. He had his chance to do that when Guy was Planning Minister. We had a Liberal Party dominated Council here in GE, as usual voting “yes” and cheering loudly to every inappropriate, unsustainable development that came before them, as well as refusing to even consider any reform to the our planning scheme that may have help the situation. And if reform had happened, we would be in a better position than we are now in.
Also remember through the Liberal Party network we suckers in Glen Eira were the first to sign up to Guys new planning amendments without any public consultation whatsoever. And what did our Honorable MP for Caulfield do our say …. let me think awhile ………. nothing.
Get real there’s an election coming up, and he’s doing what he is good at when it needs to be done.
June 24, 2018 at 5:02 PM
Delahunty is hoping she will be preselected to replace Danby in the Federal Parliament. Talk about scrapping the bottom of the barrel. Normal requirements are a Batchelor’s degree. That may rule her out. Be interesting to see her resign from Council if she was chosen as did Okotel.
June 22, 2018 at 12:39 PM
That Caulfield member soon Sold us out in the CAULFIELD vILLAGE WHICH IS RISING INTO THE HORIZON AT A FAST Rate. His ideas and campaign soon fell on the scrap heap,,, so don’t be disapppointed.
June 22, 2018 at 2:30 PM
Great work by the residents, call the Council out for what they are doing.
June 22, 2018 at 6:09 PM
The Planning System is a mess, and Liberal/Nat/Labor/Greens have all contributed to it. There are so few mandatory development standards, and the Apartment Development “standards” don’t even qualify for the name. If Skyrail is considered acceptable by the general public then as a consequence the public can expect 100% overshadowing elsewhere.
The Liberal plan is blatantly unfair, imposing poor amenity on a subset of the community to protect those zoned NRZ. Don’t expect NRZ to remain inviolate—salami tactics will apply there too, with bits periodically carved off to expand GRZ/RGZ or worse.
June 22, 2018 at 9:09 PM
100% correct, the want it all, and the Southwicks of this world will slyly hand it over, as you say piece by piece.
June 22, 2018 at 6:09 PM
Sincere or not, at least it is more than our councillors will currently say on the subject – stony silence from them. And if this issue is deemed important enough to become an election issue then at least meaningful discussions can happen. GE is, and has been, meeting its new development metrics – but that does not seem to matter, to our Councillors or expert planners when discussing the impact of 10 and 12 stories – very very sad – and yet fixable – if there was a will to listen to residents rather than call in meetings with a handful or less of large commercial landowners. Council seems fixated on high rise in Elsternwick. No grange or lobster in my household – wages static for years, we did not plan on moving house, but we need to consider whether potentially living in a high density zone is OK.
June 22, 2018 at 7:17 PM
Sad indeed that we’ve got a bunch of councillors who see community as less important than developers.
June 22, 2018 at 9:25 PM
Who knows who is being dined with Grange and Lobster and even worse. For all we know it could be the whole damned lot of these turncoat councillors.
Their behavior shows they certainly do not support residents and are in lock-step in (MODERATORS: phrase deleted) when it comes to passing the developers new planning scheme.
As now we know they have been conveniently turning a blind eye to their bureaucrat mates of not imposing the open space levy on certain favoured developers.
Everyone except the local community is doing OK out of this building boom, there is Grange and Lobster aplenty for some.
June 26, 2018 at 2:25 PM
What a great post re Delahunty, I am still laughing!!!!