Glen Eira residents have been told repeatedly that structure planning and associated Design and Development Overlays (DDOs) CANNOT provide MANDATORY height restrictions for commercial sites unless they are heritage listed or have other extenuating conditions. This of course ignores the fact that other councils have been successful in having their strategic planning approved and gazetted.
The most recent example comes from Bayside City Council for the Highett Neighbourhood Activity Centre. Here is the current zoning applying to this DDO. Note the Commercial zoning and the fact that these sites are NOT under any heritage overlay.

Here is the Bayside gazetted DDO – as recently as September this year!. Please note the 3 and 4 storey MANDATORY height limits.


Why has Bayside managed to implement a MANDATORY 3 and 4 storey maximum height limit on these sites, in comparison to Glen Eira’s 6 storey discretionary height for Caulfield South, Caulfield North and East Bentleigh? Why is our council so compliant and unwilling to achieve what other councils achieve? What is really going on within our planning department?
After 7 years of incompetency, we are still back at square one, where the agenda remains more and more development regardless of what it means for residential amenity and meeting community concerns.
December 7, 2022 at 10:43 AM
We get bullshit and spin. Other councils get results that their communities fight for.
December 7, 2022 at 10:47 AM
Thankyou for bringing this to my attention. It is also very relevant for Elsternwick.
Regards David Zyngier ________________________________
December 7, 2022 at 11:06 AM
Quite extraordinary when compared to the Elsternwick draft as you point out Cr Zyngier. Our planning department sees nothing wrong with an 8 storey (discretionary) development alongside residential properties the majority of which are either single or double storey. Hardly competent planning by any measure and definitely not aligned with community sentiment.
December 7, 2022 at 1:36 PM
I definitely want to know how other councils get a much better deal than we seem capable of getting. Maybe their planning departments fight harder, do all the necessary preliminary work, have got great advocates, and councillors do their jobs in listening to what residents say. The exact opposite of what happens in Glen Eira I suppose.