GE Transport


Things are going from bad to worse in Glen Eira in relation to planning and declining tree canopy. The latest example is an application for two 12 storey developments and 150 apartments at 1232R & 1232-1234 Glen Huntly Road, Carnegie. The application reads as follows:

Construction of two 12 storey apartment buildings above basement car parks and containing up to 150 dwellings on land in the Commercial 1 Zone, Built Form Overlay and Special Building Overlay and a reduction of carparking

Several things need to be pointed out relating to this application.

  • It directly abuts a site with a heritage overlay (HO113)
  • The surrounding residential area is zoned HCTZ1 – ie a 4 to 6 mandatory storey height limit
  • The site is not huge – 900+square metres , so basically just under 2 normal house blocks.

Thus we will have two 12 storey apartment blocks right next to current sites that are mostly double storey and possibly three storeys. We also have no idea as yet what these 150 apartments will be – ie how many single bedrooms, double bedrooms, or maybe three bedroom units? What parking reduction is being sought? Will these all be ‘build to rent’ or will they actually be sold? What of open space? Will this be the usual developer trick of assigning a 150 to 200 metre ‘open space’ somewhere on level 5, or 6, etc? If sold, will they be affordable and how many (if any) will be designated as ‘social housing’.

And since this is a ‘normal’ application at this point in time and hence will go through the old system of advertising and allowing objections, will councillors have the balls to reject such an application? Or will we get the same old bogus argument that going to VCAT will not be successful, so better not try? The developer can of course suddenly change his/her mind and go straight to the minister for approval.

We’ve already featured 2 other posts on outrageous applications. The 6 storey development in Elsternwick, which will hover over single and double storey neighbours, as well as the 22 and 24 storey developments nominated for Section 10 of the Caulfield Village project. (See these links – https://gleneira.blog/2026/11/09/the-rot-has-started-2/ and https://gleneira.blog/2026/10/19/caulfield-village/) But that’s not the end of the storey. Here are a couple of other recent applications that should cause plenty of angst among residents –

32 Cadby Avenue, Ormond – 7 triple storey on a site that is 696 square metres and surrounded by single and double storey homes.

131 Poath Road Murrumbeena – listed as a ‘multi-storey’ development, but no real detail provided in terms of height, number of units, etc.

Of equal concern is what’s happening to our tree canopy. The number of applications for development and removal of canopy trees is alarming. We have no idea as to how many applications are lodged under council’s Tree Canopy Protection Law. Council has even admitted that they have no clue as to how many trees have been removed – and all this when the Urban Forest Strategy is supposedly under review. What irks us most is that we are often not talking about single tree removal but many in one single fell swoop. Here are the latest atrocities (and one image) –

16 Marma Road, Murrumbeena – removal of 14 canopy trees

14 Duckmanton Court, Bentleigh East – removal of 7 canopy trees

20 Birdwood Street, Bentleigh East – removal of 6 canopy trees

Here’s the image of the Marma road application and the suspect trees

Yes, the State government can be blamed for much of this destruction with their pathetic planning rules. But Council also has to share much of the blame. Residents are continually left in the dark about what is happening. As we’ve stated time and again, why can other councils hold forums, feature updates on their home pages, and include commentary on applications that go directly to the Minister, whilst our lot remain silent, and in this case, we can only assume that silence equates to agreement and complicity.

There’s an article in today’s Age which should be compulsory reading for all communities impacted by the State Government’s ridiculous and destructive planning decisions. (See: https://www.theage.com.au/interactive/2026/activity-centre-brighton/index.html) What is depicted in the article has already started in Glen Eira – and not an outraged whimper from our council!!!!

We are not talking about Major Activity Centres, but our quiet residential streets!

An application has recently gone in for 71 Allison Road, Caulfield North. This was originally zoned as NRZ – a MANDATORY maximum height of 2 storeys or 8 metres. The street is overwhelmingly composed of single and double storey dwellings, with a few apartment blocks of two storeys. It is beautifully tree lined, with a few heritage sites, and runs parallel to Glen Huntly Road.

Since the government’s intervention, it is now zoned HCTZ1 –  meaning that on ‘large’ sites it can be a six storey apartment block. The site is roughly 1400 square metres, so qualifies for this height. The application reads as: Construction of a 6 storey apartment building above basement car park containing up to 33 dwellings, construction of a front fence exceeding 1.5m in height, and removal of a canopy tree.

Below are images of the immediate neighbours –

Another recent application is for 3-5 Loranne Street, Bentleigh. Again this was originally zoned NRZ but is now HCTZ2. This means 3 storeys, but on large sites can be 4 storeys. With the combined lots, the area is over 1000 square metres, so qualifies for 4 storeys. The application reads – Construction of a 4 storey apartment building above basement car park and containing up to 28 dwellings and removal of 2 canopy trees.

Again, we depict the surrounding residences –

What we are seeing is the total destruction of our residential streets and please remember that this new legislation means:

  • If the developer should decide to use the VICSMART process, then there is no notification, and no objection rights.
  • Increased site coverage allowed – ie up to 60% when NRZ was originally 50%
  • Reduction in canopy tree replacement
  • No visitor parking – with the potential for 61 units in these two streets alone
  • Council has forecast a reduction in onsite parking requirements
  • No consideration given to ‘neighbourhood character’ in most cases
  • The ability to go directly to the minister and bypass council and residents
  • No regard for heritage

We definitely commiserate with these residents who are now facing the prospect of their single storey homes being overshadowed and inundated with potential dog boxes of 6 and 4 storeys.

We will keep a close eye on what happens with these applications and any others that come in. But wouldn’t it be great if our councillors had the balls to show some real public fight back against such atrocities?!!!!!!!!

Certainly not a VILLAGE, when you will have residential towers of 24 and 22 storeys high and 3,000 apartments crammed into roughly a 6 hectare area. But the MRC is always pushing the limits.

At every stage of the Caulfield Village development, the MRC has got its way, with complete compliance by Glen Eira council. This time for the final Stage 10 precinct the MRC has gone straight to the minister for her to rubber stamp the proposed development. The plans are now being advertised and awaiting submissions from council and the public.

Residents should remember that when this Caulfield Village was first mooted, Council and the MRC produced an ‘incorporated plan’ that set height limits, setbacks, etc. For each precinct developed thus far, the heights have been well and truly exceeded. The incorporated plan had a maximum of 20 storeys for the final stage and 12 storeys surrounding the major high rise. Not any longer. What we have being proposed now are 5 buildings – one is 24 storeys, another 22 storeys and 3 others are 5 and 6 storeys.

What’s even worse, the published plans provide no detail on size of apartments, how many are single, double or triple bedrooms, how many will be for rent only and what is the definition therefore of ‘affordable’, etc. And please remember that the open space levy is only a paltry 4 and 5% for a development that will include 3,0000 apartments.

Below are some quotes from the application – each highlighting how the original ‘agreement’ between the MRC and Council means absolutely nothing.

The Incorporated Plan anticipates a yield of 1000-1200 dwellings across the Caulfield Village precinct. This dwelling target has already been substantially exceeded, with completed stages already delivering 1,636 dwellings. The current application will further contribute to housing supply through an additional 320 apartments and 782 PBSA units (800 beds), demonstrating that the inclusion of PBSA will support the objective of achieving a significant residential population at Caulfield Village, without prejudicing Glen Eira’s ability to meet its Victorian Government housing targets. The PBSA will complement the range of accommodation types and tenures already delivered in the precinct, including townhouses and apartments and build-to-rent accommodation (with affordable housing proposed under this application).

The proposal seeks approval for the following built form variations, pursuant to Clause 4.0 of the PDZ2:

• a maximum building height of 122.6 AHD (Stage 1) and 129.87 AHD (Stage 2), exceeding the preferred maximum height of 120 AHD specified under the Incorporated Plan

• a podium height of 68.07 AHD (Stage 2), exceeding the preferred maximum podium height of 63 AHD specified under the Incorporated Plan

The variations sought are modest in nature.

The proposal generates a statutary requirement to provide 580 car parking spaces……A total of 156 car spaces are proposed, resulting in a shortfall of 424 spaces. Accordingly the proposal seeks a reduction in the statutory car parking rates….

Finally, here is the rendered image of what it might look like! We have to wonder how the 5 and 6 storey buildings, and the green depictions (presumable of some open space) will fare when surrounded by 22 and 24 storey buildings?!!!!!!

The last time the community was permitted to provide input into a planning scheme review was in 2016. Thus ten years have passed, three previous reviews have come and gone and council still sees no need to allow residents to have their say on this important document which is up for decision at Tuesday’s council meeting.

The main argument council provides for the refusal to allow ‘consultation’ is (and we quote) –

Given the short time frame set by DTP, there was insufficient time to engage with the community.

However, once the Planning Scheme Review Report is endorsed by Council it will be published on Council’s website. (!!!!!!!!!!)

Council tells us that they received the order from the Minister in January 2026 that the review was to be completed by the end of October. That is a full 9 months! Ironically, when a public question was asked on the 2/5/2023 in regards to community consultation for the upcoming 2023 planning scheme review, the final paragraph of council’s answer was:

Council officers regularly brief Department of Transport and Planning representatives on the progress of our strategic planning work program and have committed to provide a review within 6 months to the Department. Once the internal review is nearing completion, Council will be in a better position to confirm the nature of any further consultation.

Needless to say, there was no community consultation then! However, council still thought that it could get things done in 6 months! Now they have 9, and we assume ongoing ‘discussions’ with the department and Minister have continued, but this isn’t enough to engage the community in 2026!

We certainly acknowledge that the last 18 months or so has seen a landslide of government changes to the planning scheme, all of which have, and will have, a dramatic impact on councils. But it’s not as if councils weren’t forewarned as to what was happening. Submissions were asked for and sent off, as well as continued ‘advocacy’.  

Thankfully, not all councils operate as Glen Eira does. To various extents, they value their communities and do provide them with the opportunity to have a say!

The following group of councils are ALL providing community consultations for their 2026 Planning Scheme Reviews. Most are regional councils so may not be impacted as severely with the Activity Centre changes as our metropolitan neighbours. But they do have their own issues to deal with that have been impacted by legislative changes – ie huge population growth in many, environment, etc.

We should also point out that not all councils have released their reviews and the processes involved. Some have asked for extensions.

The focus of this post has been on the lack of engagement with the community. Our next post will evaluate the actual review and compare it with other councils.

Cardinia – https://www.cardinia.vic.gov.au/news/draft-planning-scheme-review-part-b-public-exhibition

Mornington Peninsula – https://shape.mornpen.vic.gov.au/mps-planning-scheme-review-2026

Moonee Valley – https://yoursay.mvcc.vic.gov.au/planning-scheme-review

Mansfield – https://www.mansfield.vic.gov.au/community/news/local-knowledge-sought-2026-planning-scheme-review

Macedon Ranges – https://yoursay.mrsc.vic.gov.au/Planning-Scheme-Review

Yarra Ranges – https://shaping.yarraranges.vic.gov.au/yarra-ranges-planning-scheme-review-2026

Mansfield – https://www.mansfield.vic.gov.au/community/news/local-knowledge-sought-2026-planning-scheme-review

Kingston – https://www.yourkingstonyoursay.com.au/planning-scheme-review

Greater Dandenong – https://yoursay.greaterdandenong.vic.gov.au/strategic-planning-work-program

Whittlesea – https://www.whittlesea.vic.gov.au/Services/Building-planning-and-development/Strategic-planning/Planning-scheme-and-amendments/Planning-scheme-review

South Gippsland – https://www.southgippsland.vic.gov.au/PlanningSchemeReview2026

Baw Baw – https://www.bawbawconnect.com.au/planning-scheme-amendment-c157bawb South Gippsland – https://www.facebook.com/southgippslandshirecouncil/posts/-were-reviewing-the-south-gippsland-planning-scheme-and-we-want-you-to-share-you/1475486824605666/

Glen Eira Council has failed dismally in informing its residents as to the impact of the State Government’s ad hoc planning changes – which have all been done in indecent haste and without genuine consultation. There is no excuse why, we estimate, most of our community has no idea as to what these changes mean for their neighbourhoods and their amenity or legal rights. All that Glen Eira has managed to do is bury some waffling statements on the website that lack detail and a comprehensive analyses of consequences.

To illustrate how far other councils have gone to keep their residents informed and engaged, we’ve uploaded just one paragraph from a series of officer reports from the August 17th meeting at Boroondara. Please note all the avenues pursued by this council to ensure that their community is aware of what is happening and how it affects them.

Source: https://www.boroondara.vic.gov.au/media/121981/download?inline

Below are the HTCZ catchment rezonings for Elsternwick. We follow this up with a map showing the current areas under Heritage overlays. Please note how many remain in the ‘inner catchment zone’ – ie 4 to 6 storeys in height.

The government has today gazetted Amendment C285 which includes the final planning rules for our activity centres and surrounds. This post concentrates on these surrounds and what has changed. Areas now zoned HCTZ2 are rezoned to allow 3 storey apartment blocks and HCTZ1 four storeys and up to 6 on large sites over 1000 square metres. Heritage in these areas is largely ignored and they are in both HCTZ zones. The following gazetted map clearly outlines what has up to now largely been NRZ is finally gone!

CLICK TO ENLARGE

PS: Here’s a media release from Liveable Victoria. Nothing yet from Glen Eira!!!!

At last several councils have decided to fight the State Government’s ad hoc planning decisions with concerted legal action. The latest comes from Boroondara and their appeal to the supreme court. In contrast Glen Eira sits back and continues to be silent and compliant, despite the fact that our municipality is being torn to shreds with amendment after amendment that lacks evidence, transparency and full accountability.

Here is the Boroondara media release. (See: https://www.boroondara.vic.gov.au/your-council/news-and-media/media-centre/media-releases-and-statements/boroondara-seeks-judicial-review-ministerial-planning-permit)

Boroondara seeks judicial review on Ministerial planning permit

Tue 14 July 2026

The City of Boroondara has served Supreme Court proceedings on the Victorian Minister for Planning, Sonya Kilkenny MP, in relation to a planning permit she issued for the redevelopment of the Leo’s supermarket site in Kew. 

The Minister’s decision is being challenged because she did not appropriately consider the applicable planning controls and whether the developer had permission to use Council land to build the project.

The planning permit allows for the development of four towers on the site with a maximum height of 18 storeys, exceeding the government’s own height controls for the site (16 storeys), which were only recently published on 18 March 2026. The previous height limit for this site in the Kew Structure and Place Plan was 9 storeys and was approved by the Minister for Planning on 4 May 2017.  

The development also proposes substantial alterations to council-owned and operated land, which Council has not consented to. If changes are to be approved to this land, Council is firm that the variations need to deliver a positive result for all community members, not just the developer and residents in the new development.  

Cr Wes Gault, the Mayor of Boroondara, stressed the legal action was a last resort to achieve important changes to the project. 

“We have not made this decision lightly, but we are requesting this judicial review in the best interest of our community and residents,” he said. 

“We are not opposed to this development – in fact we agree that this is a great site for a new mixed-use development – but we want to ensure the best result for our community with a building that better fits in the space, has affordable housing, and includes a public environment that delivers for all of us.”

“We submitted extensive feedback on how this development could be improved when the Minister was considering this application, and we are disappointed that few changes were made based on this considered and constructive feedback.”

We have also asked for a meeting with the Minister for Planning in the hope these matters can be resolved without the need to continue our legal proceedings.

Specific changes the City of Boroondara would like to see include: 

  • Modifications to the building’s design to reduce overshadowing concerns and comply with the government’s own Activity Centre controls;
  • guarantees that affordable housing will be built on site;
  • better landscaping, pedestrian flows, and building materials on council owned land. This land currently delivers a public benefit, and developer modifications to this space would need to be of a high quality and fit Council expectations; 
  • ensuring that any reliance on Council land for vehicular and pedestrian access is well designed, safe and fair; and
  • ensuring access to the Council-owned land is well considered and equitable to all community members.

Boroondara is committed to ensuring that future growth is supported by great services and required infrastructure and has a long track record of supporting high-quality mixed-use developments, with thousands of new residents moving to Boroondara in recent years. 

This consistent and successful growth in Boroondara over the last 30 years, where there are few large undeveloped sites, should not be directly compared to Melbourne’s rapidly growing outer suburbs where housing estates are built in greenfield areas. 

Councillor Gault concluded by highlighting that the legal action would not change Council’s ongoing work with the Victorian Government on a range of projects from library redevelopments to the development of new sporting and parkland precincts. 

“As Councillors, we will always advocate to the Victorian Government in the best interest of our residents, and I hope we can work together to resolve this matter quickly.”

The proposed development falls within the Kew Activity Centre, one of seven within the City of Boroondara. More broadly, Council has a range of concerns regarding the use of the DFP planning permit pathway. Council believes local councils should be the decision makers for development applications lodged within their local areas, and residents should have more of a say in the developments that shape the future of their streets and neighbourhoods. 

The government’s final new zonings of HCT1 and 2, are still unknown for Elsternwick, Bentleigh and a few other activity centres. However, what is already LAW, and in operation, includes the Carnegie, Murrumbeena and Hughesdale areas, as well as Moorabbin. In an earlier post, we highlighted how these changes have impacted on Moorabbin, where countless sites were given the green light to ‘upgrade’ from 2 storey height limits, to now 3 and 4. (See: https://gleneira.blog/2026/03/26/moorabbin-before-and-after/)

Below we feature what council has had to say about some of these changes. As per usual, the negatives are totally ignored, and instead, we are told about the most miniscule of ‘positives’. No mention is made of the areas affected, nor how they will specifically be impacted. Nor are we told on what basis some of the areas can become 6 storeys. Surely, if the objective is to inform the community, then much, much more detail, and commentary is required than what we get in the following!!!!!

Catchments

Residential areas surrounding each activity centre, extending up to one kilometre, will be rezoned. These inner and outer catchments will be included in either the:

  • Housing Choice and Transport Zone 1 (4–6 storeys), or
  • Housing Choice and Transport Zone 2 (3–4 storeys)

It is pleasing to see that the catchment area around Ormond and Mckinnon has been reduced in response to submissions made by both Council and the local community.

Existing heritage precincts have not been included in the inner catchment areas, with the exception of a small section of HO72 (western side of Orrong Road south of Glenhuntly Road). A small number of individually significant heritage places will be located within the inner catchment areas. 

Source: https://www.gleneira.vic.gov.au/about-council/news/latest-news/state-government-finalises-activity-centre-plans

So residents can actually see the extent of change, we’ve uploaded the current zonings for Carnegie and its surrounds. Please note that the vast majority of these places have gone from a two storey height limit to anything between 4 and 6 storeys depending on the size of the allotment – eg Rosstown Road is now HCT1 (4-6 storeys) when it was NRZ (2 storeys). There are plenty of other such examples. But overall, the size of these catchments is overwhelming and totally destructive of what residents value about their local streets. And all council can state is that a lot is ‘pleasing’!!!!!!!!!

Check out the following image to discover what has occurred.

CLICK THE ABOVE TO ENLARGE

Next Page »