Things are going from bad to worse in Glen Eira in relation to planning and declining tree canopy. The latest example is an application for two 12 storey developments and 150 apartments at 1232R & 1232-1234 Glen Huntly Road, Carnegie. The application reads as follows:

Construction of two 12 storey apartment buildings above basement car parks and containing up to 150 dwellings on land in the Commercial 1 Zone, Built Form Overlay and Special Building Overlay and a reduction of carparking

Several things need to be pointed out relating to this application.

  • It directly abuts a site with a heritage overlay (HO113)
  • The surrounding residential area is zoned HCTZ1 – ie a 4 to 6 mandatory storey height limit
  • The site is not huge – 900+square metres , so basically just under 2 normal house blocks.

Thus we will have two 12 storey apartment blocks right next to current sites that are mostly double storey and possibly three storeys. We also have no idea as yet what these 150 apartments will be – ie how many single bedrooms, double bedrooms, or maybe three bedroom units? What parking reduction is being sought? Will these all be ‘build to rent’ or will they actually be sold? What of open space? Will this be the usual developer trick of assigning a 150 to 200 metre ‘open space’ somewhere on level 5, or 6, etc? If sold, will they be affordable and how many (if any) will be designated as ‘social housing’.

And since this is a ‘normal’ application at this point in time and hence will go through the old system of advertising and allowing objections, will councillors have the balls to reject such an application? Or will we get the same old bogus argument that going to VCAT will not be successful, so better not try? The developer can of course suddenly change his/her mind and go straight to the minister for approval.

We’ve already featured 2 other posts on outrageous applications. The 6 storey development in Elsternwick, which will hover over single and double storey neighbours, as well as the 22 and 24 storey developments nominated for Section 10 of the Caulfield Village project. (See these links – https://gleneira.blog/2026/11/09/the-rot-has-started-2/ and https://gleneira.blog/2026/10/19/caulfield-village/) But that’s not the end of the storey. Here are a couple of other recent applications that should cause plenty of angst among residents –

32 Cadby Avenue, Ormond – 7 triple storey on a site that is 696 square metres and surrounded by single and double storey homes.

131 Poath Road Murrumbeena – listed as a ‘multi-storey’ development, but no real detail provided in terms of height, number of units, etc.

Of equal concern is what’s happening to our tree canopy. The number of applications for development and removal of canopy trees is alarming. We have no idea as to how many applications are lodged under council’s Tree Canopy Protection Law. Council has even admitted that they have no clue as to how many trees have been removed – and all this when the Urban Forest Strategy is supposedly under review. What irks us most is that we are often not talking about single tree removal but many in one single fell swoop. Here are the latest atrocities (and one image) –

16 Marma Road, Murrumbeena – removal of 14 canopy trees

14 Duckmanton Court, Bentleigh East – removal of 7 canopy trees

20 Birdwood Street, Bentleigh East – removal of 6 canopy trees

Here’s the image of the Marma road application and the suspect trees

Yes, the State government can be blamed for much of this destruction with their pathetic planning rules. But Council also has to share much of the blame. Residents are continually left in the dark about what is happening. As we’ve stated time and again, why can other councils hold forums, feature updates on their home pages, and include commentary on applications that go directly to the Minister, whilst our lot remain silent, and in this case, we can only assume that silence equates to agreement and complicity.